Dry Fasting — The Record

Limits register

6. SECTION E: WHAT THE RAMADAN CLINICAL LITERATURE SAYS ABOUT MEDICALLY SUPERVISED EXEMPTION

Documented harms are kept apart from theorized ones. Every row names the source it was read from.

This is the one place where dry fasting and medicine meet in routine practice, and the structure that has emerged there is specific: the religious exemption exists, and its trigger is a clinician's assessment, not the patient's preference. Three independent sources, in three languages, from three jurisdictions, state that same structure.

E1. The international diabetes body: risk score, then instruction

IDF-DAR Practical Guidelines 2021, ISBN 978-2-930229-99-7, IDF and DAR International Alliance, Brussels, January 2021, editor Mohamed Hassanein.

READ, verbatim: > "Individuals who are in the high risk category should not fast."

> "Those at the moderate risk level are advised not to fast."

> "People with diabetes intending to fast during Ramadan should be categorised into low, moderate and high-risk groups."

> "Individuals who fast against the medical advice should follow their treating team to receive detailed guidance."

READ, on how the classification was built and ratified: > "developed using the feedback of 300 experienced physicians from across the world"

The guideline records that the classification was approved by the Mufti of Egypt (the document spells this "Mofty"). That is the mechanism by which a clinical score acquires religious force, and it is recorded here as read, not interpreted.

READ, Chapter 2: the decision to fast "is made on an individual basis and in consultation with the patient's treating physician."

READ, Chapter 1, recorded because it is the honest limitation on the whole structure: the high-risk group includes people with T1DM, pregnant women with diabetes and elderly individuals with diabetes, "many of whom will decide to fast against medical and religious advice."

E2. The religious authority: the doctor's assessment is the operative fact

Jabatan Mufti Wilayah Persekutuan (Mufti of Federal Territory's Department, Prime Minister's Department, Malaysia). "BAYAN LINNAS SIRI KE-342: RUKHSAH BERBUKA BAGI PESAKIT KRONIK: PENGARUH PENILAIAN PAKAR PERUBATAN." Dated 13 March 2026. Grade NG.

READ, verbatim Malay with translation:

> "apabila doktor menasihati untuk berbuka puasa kerana dengan berpuasa menyebabkan semakin kronik" > > "when a doctor advises breaking the fast because fasting makes the condition progressively worse"

> "Sekiranya puasa memudaratkan dirinya dan menambah kelemahannya, maka dia diharuskan berbuka puasa" > > "If fasting harms him and aggravates his weakness, he is permitted to break his fast"

> "sekiranya sakit tersebut sangat berat sehingga ditakuti boleh membawa kepada kebinasaan" > > "if the illness is so severe that it is feared it could lead to ruin"

> "apabila telah disahkan oleh doktor bahawa mereka tiada harapan sembuh" > > "once a doctor has confirmed that they have no prospect of recovery"

> "jika penyakit itu dijangka berlanjutan selama dua bulan berdasarkan sangkaan yang kuat" > > "if the illness is expected to persist for two months based on strong presumption"

> "tanpa sandaran kukuh atau pengesahan pakar, maka dia tidak dibenarkan berbuka puasa" > > "without firm grounds or a specialist's confirmation, he is not permitted to break his fast"

READ. The ruling runs in both directions. Where the illness is serious enough to threaten life or organ function, breaking the fast becomes obligatory, not merely permitted. Where there is no specialist confirmation, breaking the fast is not permitted. The judgment rests on the doctor's assessment and not on the patient's unsupported worry.

E3. The health system: an operational exemption list

NHS North East London Guidance for Safe Fasting During Ramadan, Version 1.0, March 2023, approved by the NEL Formulary & Pathways Group in February 2024, adapted by the NEL Medicines Optimisation Task and Finish Group from Tower Hamlets, Newham and Waltham Forest guidance. Grade NG.

READ, verbatim: > "Fasting is not considered compulsory for certain groups:"

The listed groups: > "People who are acutely unwell or have a long-term condition that may be worsened by fasting (physical or mental)"

> "Those who are very frail"

> "Women who are pregnant or breastfeeding or menstruating"

> "Travellers"

Condition-specific "should not fast" examples given: "Those experiencing an acute exacerbation of their chronic lung condition" and "Moderate - severe heart failure".

READ, on dehydration: > "Longer, warmer days may present an increased risk of dehydration."

That risk "can particularly affect people with existing medical problems such as diabetes, high blood pressure, heart disease/lung disease, pregnant or elderly."

E4. An Indonesian-language clinical and clerical synthesis, for the same structure

Larasati DA, Khorunisa E, Sampurna J, Nakita J, Putri Y, Dewanti ZA, Supriyadi T. "Menyikapi Cuci Darah (Hemodialisis) Saat Berpuasa di Bulan Ramadhan: Perspektif Perawat Hemodialisa dan Pandangan Ulama." Jurnal Ilmiah Keperawatan 2025;11(2):232-238. No DOI present on the document. Grade NG for its own content; the figures it cites carry the grade of their sources.

READ, verbatim Indonesian with translation: > "meningkatkan risiko dehidrasi dan mengganggu pengaturan cairan dan elektrolit" > > "increase the risk of dehydration and disrupt fluid and electrolyte regulation"

> "pembatasan cairan saat puasa dapat menyebabkan dehidrasi dan risiko cedera ginjal" > > "fluid restriction during fasting can cause dehydration and risk of kidney injury"

> "puasa yang membahayakan kesehatan sebaiknya ditinggalkan dan diganti" > > "fasting that endangers health should be abandoned and replaced"

> "Kalau dia memaksakan diri untuk berpuasa, maka penyakitnya akan semakin parah. Maka dia lebih baik tidak puasa." > > "If he forces himself to fast, his illness will worsen, so it is better for him not to fast."

MEASURED, as cited in that article from named studies (second-hand, so flagged): Emara et al. 2022, 199 haemodialysis patients in three groups, 96.6% tolerated fasting without significant complications and 3.4% had intradialytic hypotension or muscle cramps, with a significant reduction in dry weight in the fasting group. Ayu Islami & Nugroho 2024, 44 patients in East Java in three groups, no significant difference in blood pressure or weight, haemoglobin rose significantly in the full-fasting group. I did not open either of those two underlying studies. No verdict here rests on them.

READ, a stated threshold, not a measured result, recorded as such: the article describes fasting that cuts off fluid and energy intake for more than 12 hours as potentially worsening a patient's condition.

MEASURED gap: that article does not report its own sample size.

E5. What the exemption literature does NOT provide

MEASURED, denominators stated. Across all ten languages searched:

Stated plainly: the entire medically supervised exemption architecture that exists in the world was built for a 12-to-18 hour fast with overnight drinking. It was not built for, and it does not speak to, a fast in which fluid is withheld around the clock.



dryfasting.com has been published since 2014. This evidence record was compiled on 22 November 2026. Every row names the fasting modality the study actually ran, the system it was measured in and the grade. Where no source carries a DOI or PMID the row says so rather than supplying one. Nothing is sold on this site.